Must See Destinations

Best Italian Restaurants in Sarasota, Florida: From Pasta to Pizza

Banquet table with seafood

Sarasota is a city in Florida and it has deep roots of love with Italy. You will find many Italian cultural things in this city. All kinds of Italian food and italian restaurants in sarasota florida are available. In this beautiful city you will find a Renaissance art collection.

This collection includes replica of Michelangelo’s David which is so popular in the city that they also have made it its logo of Sarasota. Italy has a big influence on Sarasota as you have Asolo which is named after the small town in Italy, Venice. Venice is a region in Italy which has drawn the 18th century interior of theaters.

Italian restaurants in Sarasota Florida give a beautiful environment to their guests. The classic romantic site of Italy comes alive in this restaurant.

The taste of traditional food is here to delight your taste buds. With a lot of Italian restaurants it would not be a lie to say that Italian food is the favorite cuisine in Sarasota. By the specialized chefs you are going to have the best Italian cuisine experience in Sarasota.

Top 4 Italian Restaurants in Sarasota Florida

To have a memorable and delicate Italian cuisine here is the list of Top 4 Italian Restaurants in Sarasota Florida:

Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano

With classic and modern Italian cuisine Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano is one of the best Italian restaurants in Sarasota Florida. The restaurant provides artisanal and contemporary Northern Italian style food in their peaceful environment.

Opened in 1996 this restaurant was the first to bring authentic and traditional Italian cuisine to Sarasota. The restaurant has been under the same management and ownership of Mediterraneo. By the consistent dedication of Mediterraneo this restaurant has been the rated top restaurant in Zagat.

Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano Italian Restaurants in Sarasota Florida

Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano has also received many awards.

The Minister of Agriculture & Commerce in Rome has honored this restaurant with “Insegna Del Ristorante Italian.” But the highest honor this restaurant has received is having its name in “Fine Dining Hall of Fame.” So whether you are here to have a complete Italian cuisine or just to have a taste this restaurant is best.

Some of the most popular dishes in this restaurant are Spaghetti alla Carbonara with pancetta and creamy egg sauce. Margherita with tomato mozzarella and basil and Spinaci which is served with fresh spinach pears, pecorino cheese and walnuts.

They also serve a diverse menu of wine with their dishes. Mediterraneo always takes care of their quality that is why since their opening in 1996 they have been rated as the best of best in Sarasota Magazine.

Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastariïa

With a great passion to give the best of their service Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastariïa is making their name in the restaurant industry since March 2009. With serving best Italian dishes with hard work and integrity they have become the first traditional Neapolitan Pizzeria in Florida.

Most importantly, this restaurant gives the opportunity to show their talent to their visitors. With their 100 year old family recipes you will have a great Italian cuisine experience at Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastariïa.

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastariïa Italian Restaurants in Sarasota Florida


The story behind Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastariïa is so beautiful. Dan Bavaro and his wife Anna-Maria wanted to share their family recipes to the world so with their five children they moved from New Jersey to Tampa. So serve everyone the taste of their love for Italian food.

They provide dishes with the same energy, authenticity and love as you have at your granny house. Some of the best dishes at Bavaro are Margherita with san marzano tomato sauce.

Nutella Pizza with dough nutella spread powdered sugar and Spaghetti with two beef & pork meatballs pomodoro sauce basil oil.

Bevardi’s Salute

Located at the corner of Lemon Avenue, Bevardi’s Salute is a self owned Italian restaurant in Sarasota Florida. They serve their delightful dishes at five distinct areas: Main Dining Room, Al Fresco, Wine Room, a casual Bar and Lounge.

With beautiful seating arrangements they have been voted for the best outdoor dining, group dining and hot spot. This Italian restaurant is the best to organize private events, weddings and family gatherings with up to 200 people.

Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano


Bevardi’s Salute is known for their diverse menu. Their professionally trained chef Chef Bevardi offers variety of Italian cuisine, seafood and more. You will have imported cheese and house-made pasta in the beautiful environment. But some of the best dishes at Bevardi’s Salute are Salmone with grilled Atlantic salmon and citrus glaze.

They also provide wine, soft drinks and beer with your meal. And do have homemade dessert from their menu for a perfect finishing touch.

La Mucca Ballerina

La Mucca Ballerina is a Zappaterreno family restaurant who have served delicious meals in Agriturismo La Mucca Ballerina in Rome, Italy. This Italian restaurant in Sarasota Florida is known for its authentic Italian cuisine. Chef Mario has learned from his grandmother that Italian dining experience is not complete with just food, it is complete with a refreshing and welcoming environment. This restaurant is quite famous in the city for serving food that children have loved growing up with.

Italian Restaurants in Sarasota Florida


With a pleasant environment they serve diverse Italian cuisine in their menu. Chef Mario knows the importance of fresh homemade pasta and mozzarella. They use seasoning ingredients and pick all the vegetables by themselves to have a delightful meal.

This is not enough but the most famous dishes from this restaurant are House Salad which is a combination of Kalamata Olives, Red Onions, Tomatoes and mixed Greens Mozzarella. Rigatoni Carbonara which is made with homemade Pasta, Guanciale Egg, Yolk Pecorino & Black Pepper. Classic Italian Prosciutto, Genoa Ham, Soppressata, Pepperoni, Oregano Olive & Red Wine Vinegar.


To sum up, there are number of Italian restaurants in Sarasota Florida. These restaurants serve delicious Italian cuisine made by their professional chefs. All of the ingredients are fresh and taken from the market on daily basis. You will have some of the best homemade pasta, Spaghetti and mozzarella in these restaurants.

The environment at these restaurants will make you feel like you are dining somewhere in Italy. Apart from Italian cuisine they also have a wide variety of wines. At some restaurants you can organize weddings, family gatherings and more. Italian restaurants in Sarasota Florida are the best place to experience the best Italian cuisine.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Sarasota a foodie town?

Sarasota is a great town for foodies. You will have different cultural cuisine in this city. The city is known for its food and award-winning chefs. There are also 21 Zagat-rated restaurants in Sarasota.

What is the food scene in Sarasota?

Just like other cities in Florida, Sarasota primary cuisine is American . But you will also have other cuisine and Italian food is quite famous in Sarasota. There are also 21 Zagat-rated restaurants in Sarasota.

What food is Sarasota known for?

Just like other cities in Florida, Sarasota primary cuisine is American but you will also have other cuisine especially Italian food. Some of the food Sarasota is known for is shrimp, octopus and lobster.

What are the best Italian Restaurants in Sarasota Florida?

You will find many Italian restaurants in Sarasota and some of the best are:

  • Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano
  • Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastariïa
  • La Mucca Ballerina
  • Bevardi’s Salute